FIU and the First Amendment: The Legal Battle Over Student Protests

Edited by Ashley D'Amato

Authored by Kevin Diez

10/29/20265 min read

The FIU Protest and the University’s Response

In March 2026, a group of students at Florida International University (FIU) challenged the university’s policies on campus demonstrations after participating in a silent protest against its cooperation with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) (ICEBreakers 1-2). After the demonstration, several students faced disciplinary actions for allegedly violating the university’s policies on indoor protests. This situation raised many questions about how public universities can regulate student demonstrations while still protecting their First Amendment rights. The dispute eventually reached federal court after seven students and a student organization challenged the university’s restrictions on campus protests (ICEBreakers 1-2).

The demonstration was organized by ICEBreakers, a student organization that opposed FIU’s participation in the federal 287(g) program (Daly). The program allows certain state and local law enforcement officers to carry out immigration enforcement duties through agreements with ICE. On March 13, 2026, members of ICEBreakers attended a university event where FIU President Jeanette Nuñez was interviewing a former professional athlete (Rivero). During this event, approximately 10 to 15 students stood silently while wearing shirts displaying the message “ICE OFF FIU” (ICEBreakers 12-14).

Following the protest, FIU’s Office of Student Conduct and Academic Integrity investigated whether the students had violated Regulation 110, which restricted protests and demonstrations inside university buildings. Seven students faced disciplinary proceedings, six of whom received written warnings and were also required to complete video reflections about the university’s protest policies (ICEBreakers 16). Students who did not complete the assignment could face issues with their academic records, potentially affecting their ability to register for classes, receive financial aid, or even access their transcripts and diplomas (ICEBreakers 17). The students argued that these restrictions violated their constitutional rights and filed a lawsuit against FIU officials in federal court on August 11, 2026, raising questions about the extent of First Amendment protections for students at public universities (ICEBreakers 1-2). Organizers did not report receiving any complaints from attendees (ICEBreakers 12-14).

First Amendment Rights and University Policies

The First Amendment protects freedom of speech and expression, including the rights of students attending public universities. However, these protections do not prevent universities from establishing rules to maintain order and prevent disruptions to academic activities. One landmark Supreme Court case involving student speech is Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969). Several students were suspended for wearing black armbands to protest the Vietnam War. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of the students, establishing that schools generally can’t restrict student speech or expression without evidence that it would substantially disrupt school activities (Tinker 508-09).

Although Tinker originally involved high school students, its principles have also been considered in cases involving public universities. Colleges have a responsibility to maintain an environment where students can attend classes and participate in university activities without unnecessary interference. At the same time, students attending public universities continue to have constitutional protections for their freedom of speech (Healy 180-85). These two responsibilities became important in the FIU dispute, especially because the students protested silently without interrupting the event (ICEBreakers 12-14).

FIU’s Regulation 110 establishes different rules for demonstrations depending on where they occur on campus. Under the regulation, students are allowed to participate in outdoor protests as long as their activities are lawful and do not substantially disrupt the university’s operations or interfere with the rights of others. However, section 3 of the regulation prohibited protests, demonstrations, and similar expressive activities inside university buildings, regardless of whether they caused disruptions (ICEBreakers 10-11).

FIU maintained that these restrictions were intended to preserve university buildings strictly for educational and administrative purposes (ICEBreakers 19). The students, however, challenged the university’s ability to prohibit peaceful demonstrations simply because they occurred indoors. This difference between FIU’s indoor and outdoor policies became an important part of the legal dispute, raising questions about how universities can regulate student expression without violating the First Amendment (ICEBreakers 19-25).

The Court’s Ruling and its Legal Challenges

On August 11, 2026, ICEBreakers and seven FIU students filed a federal lawsuit against university officials, arguing that regulation 110 violated their First Amendment rights (Rivero). The students claimed that the university’s restrictions exceed what the Constitution allows because they prohibited indoor demonstrations even when they did not disrupt university activities (ICEBreakers 17-18). They also argued that the regulation was too broad and restricted protected forms of expression. As part of the lawsuit, the students requested a preliminary injunction to prevent FIU from continuing to enforce the policy against them while the case moved forward (American Civil Liberties Union of Florida).

FIU defended its regulation by arguing that Regulation 110(3) constitutes a valid restriction that is neither arbitrary nor overbroad (ICEBreakers 17). FIU further argued that the motion should be denied because the Plaintiffs have insufficient legal basis for their claims.

On August 23, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Becerra granted the students’ request for a preliminary injunction (ICEBreakers 28). The court found that the students were likely to succeed in their First Amendment challenge because FIU’s regulation prohibited indoor demonstrations without considering whether they caused any real disruption. According to the court, the demonstration did not interrupt the event. In reaching this decision, Judge Becerra relied on Tinker v. Des Moines and other legal precedents protecting student expression. The court rejected FIU’s argument that its authority to regulate university facilities justified the broad restriction, explaining that the university could still prohibit demonstrations that actually disrupted school operations (ICEBreakers 20-26).

The ruling prevented FIU officials from enforcing Regulation 110(3) against the students involved in the lawsuit and other members of ICEBreakers. Although the decision did not permanently resolve the case, it represented an important legal victory for the students. The court also explained that restricting the students’ freedom of speech, even temporarily, would violate their constitutional rights, justifying the need for action before the lawsuit was fully resolved (ICEBreakers 26-28). FIU officials appealed the preliminary injunction in September 2026, leaving the case unresolved as it continues through the courts (U.S. Court of Appeals).

The Future of Student Free Speech at Public Universities

The ruling in ICEBreakers v. Nuñez raises questions about how public universities can regulate student protests while respecting constitutional protections. Although the preliminary injunction applies to students involved in the lawsuit and other ICEBreakers members, the court’s reasoning could prove applicable to universities with similar policies. Schools can establish rules to prevent disruptions and maintain order on campus, but those restrictions must still comply with the First Amendment. The FIU case shows how policies that broadly prohibit demonstrations based on their location can face legal challenges, especially when they restrict peaceful activities that do not interfere with university operations (ICEBreakers 25-28).

The decision could also encourage universities to review their existing protest policies to ensure they do not place unnecessary restrictions on student expression. While universities have real and legitimate reasons to regulate conduct inside classrooms, offices, and other campus buildings, the court found that FIU’s policy went too far by prohibiting indoor demonstrations without considering whether they actually caused any disruption (ICEBreakers 19-26). However, the preliminary ruling doesn’t prevent FIU from enforcing other university regulations against activities that can disrupt campus operations (ICEBreakers 25-28). Although the case is still awaiting a final decision, its outcome could largely affect how campus protests are regulated in the future.

Ultimately, the dispute at FIU highlights the importance of balancing university authority with students’ constitutional rights. The federal court’s decision established that the students were likely to succeed in challenging the university’s restrictions, allowing them to continue exercising their First Amendment rights while the lawsuit proceeds (ICEBreakers 26-28). As the case moves through the courts, it might provide further guidance on how public universities can regulate student demonstrations without placing unconstitutional limits on freedom of speech.