FSU v ACC: Who Will Win?
Edited by Oleksandra Koliichuk
Pre-Game: Introducing the Legal Dispute
For years, Grant of Rights (GOR) agreements have been used to transfer exclusive rights between parties. These agreements have particularly played an important role in the college football industry, “preserving and financing conferences and universities” (Anagnos). Grant of Rights agreements specify the “permissions and entitlements that one party extends to another regarding the use of intellectual property or certain assets” (“Grants of Rights”). Despite their prevalence, “no university nor conference had ever attempted to challenge their validity before a court” (Anagnos). This was true until December 2023, when Florida State University (FSU) and the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) entered a legal dispute (Anagnos). With millions of dollars on the line, both parties tried to secure a major win: a ruling in their favor (Anagnos).
First Quarter: Background of the Case
In 1991, FSU joined the ACC, a “collegiate athletic conference headquartered in North Carolina” (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). In 2013 and 2016, FSU entered into Grant of Rights agreements that granted the ACC certain television and media rights to broadcast FSU’s home games through 2036 (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The ACC subsequently entered into media contracts with ESPN, allowing it to broadcast games (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). In March 2024, Dr. James E. Ryan, the Board of Directors chair for FSU, declared that the ACC became “aware in August 2023 that Florida State ‘appeared to either be considering a withdrawal from the ACC, a challenge to the Grant of Rights agreement, or both’” (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). According to Ryan, the ACC was initially against filing a lawsuit unless FSU seemed likely to breach its agreement. (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees).
Second Quarter: The Action
On December 21, 2023, the ACC initiated legal action against FSU’s Board of Trustees in North Carolina (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The ACC wanted to ensure that the GOR agreements remained valid and enforceable (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The following day, December 22, 2023, the FSU Board filed a “declaratory judgment complaint in Leon County to obtain a ‘definitive understanding of the financial consequences’” of withdrawing from the ACC (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). FSU challenged the enforceability of the ACC’s withdrawal penalties and raised additional claims involving contractual obligations, Florida’s public policy, and trustee duties.
In response, the ACC filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the North Carolina case should take priority because North Carolina filed first and that both parties were suing over substantially similar issues (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The FSU Board argued that a stay was unnecessary because “the ACC’s North Carolina action was an anticipatory filing” (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The Florida trial court agreed and denied the ACC’s request.
Third Quarter: The Result
Subsequently, the ACC petitioned Florida’s First District Court of Appeal to overturn the trial court’s decision. The ACC argued that an “anticipatory filing cannot constitute an exceptional circumstance that would justify the denial of a priority-based stay” (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The ACC conceded this claim during oral argument, ultimately recognizing that an anticipatory filing “constitute[s] an additional, exceptional, or extraordinary circumstance” (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). Anticipatory filing in this context refers to parties racing to file a lawsuit in the court of preference due to the anticipation that the opposing party will file first (Cavendish). Courts have the discretion to dismiss a court case if it qualifies as anticipatory.
Backed by established case law, the ACC’s concession led the appellate court to conclude on November 4, 2024, that the trial court “did not depart from the essential requirements of the law in its analysis” (Atlantic Coast Conference v. Florida State University Board of Trustees). The decision allowed FSU’s lawsuit to proceed in Florida, but did not resolve the underlying disagreement over the enforceability of the GOR agreements.
Fourth Quarter: The Final Whistle
With the 2024 appellate decision leaving the underlying legal issue unresolved, the ACC, Clemson, and Florida State issued a joint statement. On March 4, 2025, the parties announced that all ongoing legal disputes had been resolved. The statement confirmed that “Clemson and Florida State will remain full members of the ACC and the parties will dismiss all pending lawsuits in the states of Florida, North Carolina, and South Carolina” (“ACC, Clemson, and Florida State”). Rather than pursuing a final judicial ruling on their GOR agreements, both parties negotiated a settlement. The settlement allows members of the ACC to earn monetary benefits based on performance and reduces exit fee structures, allowing a more affordable path to explore conference affiliation (Best & Lahtinen). While the overall case ended with both universities remaining in the ACC, it highlighted the importance of contractual agreements and financial challenges that may arise in college football and emphasized that scoring touchdowns is not the only thing on the line.