LGBTQ+ Exclusion from Title IX: What This Means for Students

Edited by Detmer Steffensen

Authored by Ashley Moreau

11/16/20263 min read

Trump rescinds Biden-era Title IX policies

On September 28, 2026, the White House formally announced the reversal of the Biden administration's policies that expanded Title IX (a federal law prohibiting discrimination in educational institutions that receive federal funding) protections to LGBTQ+ students. The White House stated that this action would restore Title IX to serve its original purpose, which it described as “...protect women’s safety, dignity, and educational opportunities in schools that receive federal funding,” specifically mentioning female transgender athletes’ participation in women’s sports (The White House). This decision has faced significant backlash from LGBTQ+ advocacy groups, although the exact impacts of the change are contested.

Advocacy groups condemn changes

Critics of the return to the 2020 Title IX regulations under the first Trump administration have claimed that they significantly weaken protections for LGBTQ+ students in higher education. Advocates for sexual assault victims have also been vocal, expressing that the wiping out of the previous Title IX regulations harms victims of sexual assault by narrowing the definition of what is considered sexual assault. Shiwali Patel, senior director at the National Women’s Law Center, responded, “Education Secretary Linda McMahon and the Trump administration have decided to ignore what survivors need, instead of weaponizing Title IX to attack trans students” (Bender). The President of the Human Rights Campaign, Kelley Robinson, further states that “We know who will be hurt: women, girls, and others who are vulnerable to sexual harassment, assault, and abuse- including LGBTQ+ students” (Luneau). This highlights the argument among advocacy groups that the administration is pushing an anti-LGBTQ+ agenda at the expense of victims of abuse.

Questions swirl around impacts

While the new language of the Title IX regulations excludes protections against discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, scholars argue that this change does not make discrimination against LGBTQ+ individuals in educational settings permissible. Federal courts around the country have determined that discrimination based on sex (which remains in the Title IX regulations) includes discrimination based on sexual orientation or transgender status. Specifically, the 2020 Supreme Court case Bostock v. Clayton County determined that discrimination based on sexual orientation is included under sex-based discrimination (GLAD Law).

In Bostock v. Clayton County, the Supreme Court had to determine whether discrimination based on sexual orientation could be considered sex-based discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Bostock stated that he was fired from his position for openly expressing his sexual orientation and joining a gay softball league. Bostock’s lawyers argued that he was fired because he failed to conform to a sex stereotype, and that an employer would have to ascertain the sex of an individual before making any determinations about that employee's sexual orientation. The plaintiffs argued that this constituted sex-based discrimination because it penalized an employee for not conforming to what is considered a sex-based trait (Legal Information Institute). In a 6-3 decision, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Bostock and asserted that to take action against an employee based on sexual orientation is to take into account the sex of that employee (Schacter). Scholars have argued that because of this ruling, the Trump administration’s exclusion of LGBTQ+ individuals in Title IX has little effect. Some argue that the inclusion of sex-based discrimination in Title IX protections extends to discrimination based on sexual orientation. These changes do not necessarily allow educational institutions to discriminate against LGBTQ+ students.

Gender identity in athletics under scrutiny

Transgender athletes who compete for schools with federal funding may no longer be allowed to participate in light of changes to Title IX and the ruling in Supreme Court case B.P.J. v. West Virginia State Board of Education. In its revisions to Title IX, the Department of Education bars female transgender athletes from using single-sex bathrooms and locker rooms, and prohibits them from competing in athletics. In a press release, the White House further announced that it had launched Title IX investigations into the California Community College Athletic Association, The New Richmond School, and Western Carolina University over claims that they allow female transgender students to compete in sports (The White House). The exclusion of gender identity as a part of Title IX and the active efforts being made to block female transgender athletes from participating in sports were also upheld by the Supreme Court.

The future remains unclear

The Trump Administration’s exclusion of sexual orientation and gender identity in Title IX, while concerning to LGBTQ+ students and advocacy groups, is debated among scholars. Many argue that court rulings, such as the Supreme Court’s ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, still protect LGBTQ+ students under Title IX. In contrast, others point to cases such as B.P.J. v. West Virginia Board of Education as an example of the contrary. Whether or not this exclusion will have long-term impacts on LGBTQ+ students attending federally funded universities, and the future of female transgender athletes' participation in sports, is subject to future legal proceedings that will seek to define the bounds of the new Title IX regulations.