Public Discord Messages Made Discoverable: The Broader Conversation on Social Media and Privacy

Edited by Danielle Young

Authored by Jaden Juarez

11/16/20263 min read

Privacy in the Social Media Era

On October 27, 2026, Discord announced that some messages from public channels would become discoverable on search engines starting in mid-December, raising concerns over privacy on the platform and across social media (Seipel). Discord is far from the first social media platform to spark privacy concerns; Instagram discontinued end-to-end encrypted messaging (E2EE) on May 8, 2026, drawing similar public responses (Tidy). With many Discord users valuing their privacy, the platform has offered users and server owners the option to opt out of making their content discoverable (Seipel). While both companies have offered their own rationale for these changes, users have varying opinions on the implications going forward.

Considering the billions of active social media users globally, how large social media platforms handle user data and privacy means new changes can have widespread effects (Shahriar et al.). Among college students, studies indicate growing concerns over privacy and data collection ushered in by social media and the digital age (Marazziti et al.). An estimated 70% of college students use social media daily, and more than 75% use these platforms for more than one hour per day, situating this demographic squarely in the pool of users subject to the privacy-related changes made by these companies (Astleitner and Schlick). Past and current cases can show how discussions surrounding social media and privacy have changed and where they could go.

Privacy Concerns in Recent History

The Facebook-Cambridge Analytica scandal is a formative case in the current discussion of privacy on social media platforms. A Cambridge Analytica whistleblower brought the incident to light on March 17th, 2018, reporting the company’s use of over 50 million Facebook profiles to conduct data modeling for political ads (Harbath). Both companies underwent investigations that spurred global discussions on the potential privacy risks with the use of these platforms (Harbath). Within the last month, a judge in New Mexico ordered Facebook (now Meta) to pay the state $25 billion after being found liable for deceiving users about their privacy, stemming from this incident years ago (Schuettler).

Similarly, TikTok has experienced controversy regarding user data collection practices. Critics mainly focused on the collection of sensitive data from American users and potential ties to China. However, TikTok denied these claims (Busch). These legal and privacy-related concerns culminated in the app being temporarily banned from app stores on January 19th, 2025, and going offline for about 14 hours (Allyn). Today, TikTok is online and accessible, though discussions continue about the platform's data collection practices.

For Meta and TikTok, privacy concerns mainly include sensitive data collection that reveals more than just algorithmic preferences, but also personally identifiable information such as date of birth, location, and phone numbers (“These Social Media Platforms Harvest the Most Personal Data”). As the government pressures companies to be more transparent about these practices, a reported 38% of Americans have used social media less frequently out of concern for their privacy (“These Social Media Platforms Harvest the Most Personal Data”).

Ongoing Privacy Concerns

Ongoing privacy discussions have less to do with the type of data platforms potentially collect and more with how easily users' information on these platforms can be accessed. The aforementioned Discord decision is an example of this new type of privacy concern, where public servers and the discussions within them gain visibility when searched for online (Duncombe-Smith). In a similar vein, Instagram removing E2EE messaging means Meta has access to the content of users’ chats. (Tidy).

Proponents of these changes made to Instagram argue that they make the platform safer, especially for children (Tidy). If a crime were to occur, it would be much easier to access the chat logs and hold the perpetrators accountable (Tidy). Privacy advocates have differing viewpoints, arguing that E2EE was a surefire way to keep private conversations private (Tidy). These debates reveal the nuance in discussing privacy on these platforms, and the potential trade-offs between prioritizing safety or prioritizing confidentiality.

Social Media Privacy Going Forward

The digital age only marches onward, and social media has become more ingrained in society and daily life. The privacy debate has two prongs: what kind of data is being collected and what information about users is being made more readily accessible to the public. Studies indicate a degree of concern among college students, highlighting potential gaps in policy and regulation on social media platforms when it comes to safeguarding the privacy of their users (Marazziti et al.). Ultimately, there is always some degree of anonymity sacrificed when interacting online; the degree of anonymity sacrificed is what can be disputed.