The Climate Disclosure Fight: The SEC’s Stalled Rules and the Push to Rescind Them

Edited by Madison Choi

Authored by Lucas Landman

10/29/20262 min read

The Controversial Regulation

In March 2024, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued a regulation that would have required most public companies to disclose climate-related risks to their business, certain greenhouse gas emissions, and the financial effects of severe weather events in their annual reports (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “The Enhancement and Standardization”). These rules were almost immediately challenged by states and businesses alike. The challenges culminated in a consolidation of petitions brought before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit in the case Iowa v. SEC (Jones Day). The SEC stayed the rules in April 2024, temporarily suspending the rules while the litigation was pending, and the regulation never took effect (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “Order Issuing Stay”).

The Arguments

States and business groups argued that the SEC lacked clear statutory authority to require the disclosures this regulation requested (Onnela et al.). The groups asserted that these rules raised a major questions problem, referencing a Supreme Court rule stating that federal regulatory agencies cannot issue major regulations with significant economic or political influence unless authorized by Congress (Onnela et al.). Specifically, they contended that Congress had not clearly authorized the agency to impose this kind of climate-related reporting, and that this was indeed a significant change because the ruling would force companies to undergo extraneous and expensive data collection to gather the information required in SEC reports. They also claimed the rulemaking process that resulted in this regulation violated the Administrative Procedure Act, a federal statute that established the procedures agencies must abide by to create, repeal, or amend rules (Onnela et al.). These groups argued that the final rule differed so much from the original proposal that the SEC needed to issue a new proposal and have a new comment period (Uyeda). The final argument proposed by opponents claimed that the rules required companies to make climate-related disclosures, raising concerns about compelled speech on the politically charged topic (Onnela et al.).

How the SEC and Courts Have Responded

In April 2024, the SEC chose to stay the climate-disclosure rules while the Eighth Circuit litigation was pending. In practice, the rules never took effect (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “Order Issuing Stay”). In March 2025, this position was upheld as the SEC voted to stop defending the rules in court (Jones Day). Five months later, in September 2025, the Eighth Circuit placed the case in abeyance and directed the SEC to decide whether to change, withdraw, or defend the rules (Reuters). In May 2026, the SEC proposed to fully rescind the 2024 climate disclosure rules (Uyeda). The comment period for this proposal closed in August 2026, and the agency is now reviewing the comments received (Jones Day).

What Remains In Force

Until the SEC adopts a final rule rescinding the 2024 climate disclosures, the Commission's 2010 interpretive release on climate-related disclosure still applies (Jones Day). The older guidelines do not impose the specific emissions disclosure and/or financial-statement release requirements mandated by the newer stayed rules. However, some state laws require more intensive disclosure and testing than federal standards mandate. In California, state laws require large companies to report greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related financial risks (Jones Day). Those state-specific requirements are independent and enforced separately from the SEC's stayed rules (Jones Day). The Eighth Circuit litigation and the SEC’s rescission process together raise a broader question about the scope of an agency's authority to regulate the industries under its jurisdiction in relation to climate-centered issues.