The Scandal Looming Over Florida’s Midterm Elections

Edited by Detmer Steffensen

Authored by Ashley Moreau

10/29/20264 min read

The midterms are heating up

A political scandal involving the distribution of $10 million to political action committees (PACs) could shake up Florida’s midterm elections. The individuals involved in the scandal, including Attorney General James Uthmeier, Governor Ron DeSantis, First Lady Casey DeSantis, and Senator Ashley Moody, have raised questions that the Republican Party may have to address in the upcoming elections. While the impacts of the scandal will not be known until the election results are announced, the potential fallout remains a concern to Florida politicians.

Involvement remains unclear

In 2024, $10 million from a $67 million Medicaid settlement was diverted to a PAC headed by then Chief of Staff James Uthmeier, who now serves as attorney general. The money first went through the Hope Florida Foundation, then was later distributed to two nonprofits that supported PACs that opposed the legalization of recreational marijuana and the right to abortion in the state constitution. (CBS Miami Team). The distribution of these funds from the settlement has been the subject of intense scrutiny and legal action.

The Hope Florida Foundation was established by First Lady Casey DeSantis to keep families off of public welfare by connecting them with churches and aid groups. Following the release of a leaked grand jury report, there are allegations that the foundation misused taxpayer money to fuel a political agenda (Mazzei and Ovalle). This report brought the scandal to light and has raised questions regarding its legality and the future of investigations into the foundation. The report stated, “We can plainly see that taxpayer money was misused for political purposes and we would like to see changes made to prevent this from happening again” (Castor). Both James Uthmeier and Ashley Moody (who was at that time serving as the state’s attorney general) were implicated. Specifically, the grand jury determined that Moody’s office knew about the payments and that the payments were approved by the chief deputy. However, the grand jury lacked evidence to prove who specifically was responsible for distributing these funds. Additionally, witnesses in the case stated that they could not recall who directed the money to the foundation (Mazzei and Ovalle). Due to an inability to identify who was responsible for diverting the funds, questions have emerged about the validity of the grand jury’s findings and whether Florida Democrats should use the scandal to rally opposition against Republican candidates.

Florida Republicans face intense scrutiny

Following the leak of the grand jury report, the Florida Democratic Party moved swiftly to criticize the Republican Party and the individuals implicated in the findings. Florida Democratic Party Chair Nikki Fried released a statement saying, “Floridians deserve to trust that their government is free of corruption…I’m calling on the RPOF to do the right thing and give the millions of dollars they stole from Floridians back to the State of Florida” (Florida Democratic Party). Democratic candidates David Jolly and Angie Nixon have also used the Hope Florida scandal to call out their opponents.

Jolly, who is running for governor against Republican candidate Byron Donalds, has stated that he would reopen the investigation into the matter if elected. In an interview, Jolly stated that he believed the grand jury report to be flawed because “...when all of the subjects of the investigation are the ones capable of covering it up, it’s clear that this was not an impartial way to get fact-finding” (DeFede). Senator candidate Angie Nixon has used the Hope Florida scandal to criticize her opponent Ashley Moody, and has used it to portray Moody as a corrupt politician. Nixon, when asked about the Hope Florida scandal and her opponent in an interview with Politico, said, “...Ashley Moody needs to be investigated, and if she did in fact steal money from sick kids, which I believe she did, she needs to be jailed and put in prison” (Vasquez). The Hope Florida scandal and Democrats' calls for further investigation have become a central part of their appeal to voters by portraying Republican leadership in the state as corrupt.

Uthmeier and the Republican Party fire back

In support of Democratic candidates in Florida, the Florida Democratic Party released advertisements about the leaked grand jury report. In response to these advertisements, Uthmeier petitioned a court to stop these ads from being aired, and the Republican Party of Florida filed a lawsuit against TV stations and the Democratic Party. Both Uthmeier and the Republican Party argued that the ads violated state laws by talking about the expunged grand jury report (Ellenbogen and Garcia). As Election Day approached, efforts to remove the advertisements intensified.

The advertisements were created in support of David Jolly, attorney general candidate Jose Javier Rodriguez, and chief financial officer candidate Annette Taddeo. Uthmeier claimed in a motion that the depictions of him in the ad, portraying him as involved in the scandal and his actions as illegal and corrupt, showed “ill motive” because it neglected to mention that in the expunging report, the judge presiding said the $10 million transfer was not misappropriation, but was rather a lawful executive action (Ellenbogen and Garcia). These requests were denied by Circuit Judge Peter Estrada on October 20, stating that the party must serve a legal notice to the TV stations they want the ads removed from before he can consider their request (Matat). This issue was resolved shortly after Judge Estrada denied the Republican Party's request. The Democratic Party stopped airing the ads, stating that they were only meant to be run for a limited time, and the Republican Party dropped the lawsuit (Ellenbogen and Garcia). Whether this lawsuit and the impact of the ads will sway voters is a question that can only be answered after election results begin to roll in.

The controversy surrounding Hope Florida and the Republican Party's subsequent response may determine how voters view candidates Uthmeier and Moody. Until the results of the election, the impacts of the Hope Florida scandal on voters remain unknown.